Why were Venus's observed phases the single most powerful proof for the Sun being central?
Answer
A full phase of Venus is impossible to see if it orbits the Earth
In the Ptolemaic system, Venus could only appear as a crescent or new phase. Seeing Venus exhibit a full illuminated face was a direct consequence only explainable if Venus orbited the Sun.
Related Questions
What view placed the Earth motionless at the center of the universe prior to Galileo?When was Nicolaus Copernicus's seminal work proposing the heliocentric theory published?What specific observation by Galileo most devastatingly challenged the idea that everything in the heavens orbited the Earth?Why were Venus's observed phases the single most powerful proof for the Sun being central?What complex mathematical feature did Ptolemy and others employ in the geocentric model to explain retrograde motion?What was the initial weakness of Copernicus's heliocentric theory before Galileo's observations?How did Galileo's observation of sunspots challenge the ancient understanding of celestial bodies?In what year did the Catholic Church formally declare the heliocentric model to be 'formally heretical'?Which of Galileo's published works was perceived as a direct violation of the 1616 injunction when released in 1632?What was the consequence imposed upon Galileo after the Roman Inquisition trial in 1633?