Why did observing a fully illuminated Venus contradict the Ptolemaic system?
Answer
The geocentric model predicted Venus could only appear as a crescent or new phase.
The Earth-centered model positioned Venus always between the Earth and the Sun, meaning only crescent or new phases should be visible; observing a fully illuminated Venus was physically impossible under that arrangement.
Related Questions
What fundamental scientific methodology did Galileo champion?What was the approximate maximum magnification Galileo achieved with his improved telescopes?What did Galileo document about the surface of the Moon?What philosophical division did the observation of an imperfect Moon help dissolve?What celestial bodies did Galileo observe orbiting Jupiter in early 1610?What name did Galileo initially give to the moons orbiting Jupiter?What key phenomenon did Galileo observe regarding the planet Venus?Why did observing a fully illuminated Venus contradict the Ptolemaic system?What Aristotelian concept regarding motion did Galileo's work challenge?According to Galileo, what language is the book of nature written in?What was the title of Galileo's work that brought him into direct conflict with the Catholic Church?