What would likely happen to the appearance of the sky if Earth had a substantially thicker atmosphere than it currently does?
Answer
The sky would appear darker, perhaps even black, with the direct solar disk being the only visible light source.
A much thicker atmosphere means a longer path length for all light, causing even longer wavelengths like red to scatter significantly, thereby removing almost all light from the general sky area.

#Videos
The Sky Is NOT Blue. Eye doctor reveals the truth behind ... - YouTube
Related Questions
What physical phenomenon underlies the blue color observed in the sky?How is the intensity of light scattering during Rayleigh scattering dependent on the wavelength (λ)?If violet light scatters more intensely than blue light, why does the sky primarily appear blue?What role does human biology play in perceiving the sky as blue rather than violet?Which molecules in the atmosphere are chiefly responsible for scattering sunlight?Why does the sun appear yellower or whiter when viewed directly overhead during the day?What characteristic must light possess to undergo Rayleigh scattering effectively?During sunset, why do we observe yellows, oranges, and reds in the direct beam of the sun?What would likely happen to the appearance of the sky if Earth had a substantially thicker atmosphere than it currently does?The argument suggesting the 'blueness' is an illusion shifts focus from optics primarily to which area?What concept, reinforced culturally since childhood, is activated when a person labels the expanse above as 'sky blue'?