What was the first critical visual clue that suggested the object was not a distant star?

Answer

It possessed a measurable disc shape

Stars appear as perfect, unresolved points of light, but Herschel noted that this object had a measurable disc, suggesting it was a nearer, reflecting body like a planet or nebula.

What was the first critical visual clue that suggested the object was not a distant star?
discoveryastronomyHerscheltelescopeplanet